5 Signs Your Supply Chain Team Has Outgrown Your People Strategy
In this week’s newsletter I break down 5 signs your supply chain team has outgrown your people strategy, with the research behind each one and what they usually say about how a team is being managed. If you lead people in HR or operations, I think you will recognize at least two of them.
Fernanda Brasileiro
11/5/20265 min read
I have spent more than 20 years in global supply chain and operations. I served brands like McDonald's and Starbucks and worked inside organizations like Krispy Kreme and Sears. Across all of those environments, I have watched the same pattern repeat. The network gets optimized, the technology gets upgraded, the forecasts get sharper, and the people strategy stays frozen in whatever year someone last updated it.
Supply chain teams change faster than almost any other function. Disruptions, tariffs, automation, and AI keep rewriting the work. When the way you develop, reward, and retain people stays still while the work keeps moving, the gap shows up in predictable ways. Here are the five signs I see most often.
1. Your succession plan is a spreadsheet, not a pipeline
Ask a supply chain leader whether they have a succession plan, and most will say yes. Ask who is ready to step into a critical role within six months and what that person has done to get ready, and the room gets quiet. A name in a column is not a successor. A successor who is ready has gone through stretch assignments and structured development over 18 to 24 months (including cross-functional exposure) .
The data shows how costly this gap is. Gartner's 2025 survey of 227 supply chain leaders found that 54% report leadership turnover significantly disrupted their operations in the past three years. Fewer than half (49%) rate their leadership development programs as effective. One study from Auburn University and Central Michigan University found that 37.5% of surveyed companies had not engaged in succession planning. Only 12.5% engaged in formal succession planning. That research is older, but in my experience the pattern has not changed much. Plans get written for an audit or a talent review and then sit untouched until someone resigns.
If your plan has not been updated since your last reorganization, it describes a team that no longer exists.
2. Your best people are picking up everyone else's slack
Every supply chain team has someone who always gets it done. When a teammate is underperforming and the work still has to be done, that person ends up inheriting the overflow. Leaders see the results and feel relief. The high performer sees something different: a reward for excellence that looks exactly like a penalty.
Burnout researcher Christina Maslach identifies workload mismatch as one of six key drivers of burnout. Overloaded high performers also become single points of failure. When one person holds the knowledge and carries the load, one resignation stalls a whole function. Conservative estimates put the cost of replacing an employee at 1.5 to two times their annual salary. That figure doesn't include the institutional knowledge that walks out the door.
The root cause may not be the high performer themselves. It is likely a manager who has not addressed the underperformance directly. So the team ends up paying for a conversation that never happened.
Gartner's research makes a related observation: effective supply chain leadership has to shift away from an overreliance on individual superstars. Research found those superstars are often less collaborative. The recommendation is to move toward leaders who are motivated and equipped to lift the performance of their teams.
3. Calibration is flattening your top talent
Performance calibration is supposed to create fairness. When it is handled poorly, it does the opposite. I have seen high performers receive the same "meets expectations" rating as everyone else because:
of forced distributions,
ratings were spread around to keep peace,
or because leaders inflated a struggling employee's rating to avoid a hard conversation.
The high performer finds out at review time, and the effect on motivation is immediate.
People who have been working well above their level and get an average rating start asking what the point is.
Your rating and reward systems need to tell the truth about who is delivering and how they are doing it.
4. Growth has stalled, and promotions are promises, not plans.
Gallup's research is consistent on this point. The number one reason people leave an employer is a lack of career opportunities. Gallup's exit research also found that 52% of exiting employees say their organization could have done something to keep them from leaving. Yet in the three months before they left, less than three in ten had a conversation about the future of their career with the organization.
Supply chain leaders feel this too. In Gartner's survey, only 37% agreed that the process for promotions is transparent. When a high-potential employee has no picture of what comes next, and has been told for the third year in a row that a promotion is "coming next quarter," they do the math. Empty promises are worse than no promises, because they teach your best people that you don't keep your word.
A growth conversation costs a manager 30 minutes. Skipping it costs you the person.
5. A reorganization left your team unsure whether they can trust leadership
Reorganizations are often necessary. But the way they are handled determines whether the team comes out stronger or comes out guarded. Bain & Company's 2026 research found that:
88% of leaders believe their new structure will achieve its goals,
while only 36% of employees working in it agree.
Only 22% of employees felt they received sufficient support, including training, coaching, or tools.
A separate survey of US workers found that among those who had been through layoffs or restructuring, only 6% said leadership clearly explained the reasons behind it.
In supply chain, the gap between those numbers means a significant performance problem. Supply chain teams' reliability depends on trust between planners, procurement, buyers, logistics, and operations. Without that trust, people stop raising issues early. They protect themselves. The speed and candor that great supply chain execution depends on start to fade.
What these five signs have in common
Look at the list again, and a theme emerges. Outdated succession plans, overloaded top performers, muddy calibration, empty promotion promises, and rushed reorganizations all come from the same place. Management that is making short-term decisions without a long-term picture of its people. Each decision made sense in the moment. Together they add up to a team that has outgrown the strategy meant to support it.
The good news is that this is fixable, and it starts with your managers. In fact, Gallup found that 70% of the time, what employees said would have kept them from leaving was how they were managed on a daily basis. Managers who can have honest performance conversations, distribute work fairly, and talk about what comes next. They are the foundation of any people strategy that keeps pace with the work.
If you want a place to start, I created a short resource called 5 Signs Your Managers Are Struggling. This helps you spot the manager-level patterns behind many of the issues above. You can get it here: fernandabrasileiro.com/diagnostic
And if this edition was useful, I would love to have you as a subscriber. Each edition of Passion 4 People Development brings you practical, research-backed ideas for building teams that thrive. Hit subscribe, and tell me in the comments which of the five signs you see most often in your own organization. I read every response.
Fernanda Brasileiro
Supply Chain Advisory • Leadership Development
CONNECT
© 2026. All rights reserved.
GET FREE TEAM DIAGNOSTIC
